Let me say the thing nobody wants to admit at the Thanksgiving table: cooking the whole thing yourself is a lot. It’s a beautiful tradition and a complete logistical nightmare, and somewhere around the third hour of babysitting a turkey while six side dishes fight for one oven, a quiet little voice asks whether this was ever actually necessary. I love to cook. I grew up in a kitchen in Audubon where Thanksgiving was a full-contact sport. And I am here to tell you, with no shame whatsoever, that letting somebody else do it — or do part of it — is one of the smartest moves you can make, and South Jersey makes it easy.
The restaurant roundups are already out. SJ Magazine has published its annual list of South Jersey spots offering special Thanksgiving menus, and both the Inquirer and the regional food writers have their yearly guides to the places that are open on the day and the places that will cook the whole dinner for you to carry home. This happens every November, and every November the same thing goes wrong for the same people: they wait too long. By the time they decide, the good tables are booked and the to-go order lists are closed.
Three ways to do it
So this is less a review than a public service, and the service is this: decide now.
There are, broadly, three ways to do this, and all three are legitimate. One, you go out — a proper sit-down dinner at a restaurant that’s open on Thanksgiving, somebody else’s turkey, somebody else’s dishes, and you walk out full without having scrubbed a single roasting pan. Two, you order the whole feast to go — a growing number of South Jersey kitchens, from white-tablecloth spots to the diners and family restaurants that are the backbone of eating around here, will cook a complete Thanksgiving dinner that you pick up and reheat, so your table still looks homemade and nobody has to know. Three — and this is my personal favorite — you cook the parts you love and farm out the parts you dread. Make your grandmother’s stuffing. Buy the pie. Roast the turkey but let the bakery handle the dinner rolls and the dessert. There is no prize for suffering.
There is no prize for suffering.Sophia Marino
The pie deadline
And speaking of pie: if you want a good one from a real South Jersey bakery, that train is leaving the station. The order-ahead lists at the best spots fill up fast in the final week, and a lot of them simply stop taking orders once they hit capacity, because a bakery can only turn out so many pies between now and Thursday. The same goes for fresh turkeys from the local farms and butchers — the ones worth having are spoken for early. If you’ve been meaning to call, today is the day the calling actually works.
What I love about the South Jersey version of all this is how unpretentious it is. In some parts of the country, eating out on Thanksgiving carries a whiff of defeat, like you failed some domestic test. Not here. Around here, the diner is sacred, the family restaurant is an institution, and the idea that a good meal has to be one you personally sweated over is treated with the suspicion it deserves. We are a region that understands that the point of the holiday is the people at the table, not the martyrdom of the person who cooked. If letting the restaurant down the street handle the turkey means you’re actually relaxed and present when everyone sits down, then the restaurant down the street just made your holiday better. That’s a win.
Lock it in
So here’s my honest, hungry advice for the week ahead. Figure out which kind of Thanksgiving you want — out, to-go, or a smart split — and lock it in before the weekend is over. Check the roundups, call the restaurant or the bakery, and get your name on the list while there’s still a list to get on. The food will be good. South Jersey kitchens don’t phone it in on the holidays. But the one thing they can’t do is hold a spot for someone who waited too long.
Pick up the phone. Then go enjoy your weekend. You’ve earned the easy version.
Based on Thanksgiving dining roundups from SJ Magazine and The Philadelphia Inquirer.
More South Jersey Food
Sophia Marino covers where South Jersey eats, all year long.
Read More Local News →