PHILADELPHIA — Four days ago, Nick Sirianni stood at a podium and told the city exactly where he stood on his quarterback. “Tanner’s our guy,” the coach said on Nov. 2. “We’re not making any changes there.”
By Wednesday afternoon, they’d made the change.
Joe Milton III — signed off the Dallas Cowboys’ practice squad less than a month ago, a man who has never started an NFL game — is reportedly set to take the first snap Sunday against the New York Giants, 1 o’clock at the Linc, with Tanner McKee headed to the bench. That’s the news, per multiple national reports. And if you want to understand how far this season has fallen for the 2-6 Philadelphia Eagles, you don’t need the standings. You just need that sentence.
Six straight losses, a carousel at quarterback
I grew up in Camden watching this franchise, and I’ve seen plenty of ugly Novembers. But there’s a specific flavor to this one. This isn’t a team losing with its guys. This is a team six games into a losing streak, cycling through quarterbacks the way you’d flip through a deck looking for a card that isn’t there. Jalen Hurts, the Super Bowl MVP, is on injured reserve and out for the year with blood clots — a genuinely scary thing that puts a football season in its proper, smaller place. Andy Dalton threw one pass, an interception, and got released. McKee got three starts and went 0-3 behind a line that couldn’t keep him upright. And now the keys go to a 6-foot-5 kid with a cannon for an arm who was a Cowboy a few weeks ago.
Here’s what I’ll say in McKee’s defense, because somebody should: you cannot fairly evaluate a quarterback playing behind an offensive line that can’t keep the pocket clean. The kid never had a chance to find a rhythm. The decision to move on, the reports say, isn’t about injury — it’s about mobility, about finding someone who can escape the collapse the line keeps handing the quarterback. Milton can run, and in an offense that can’t block and can’t run, “he can move” has apparently become the whole résumé requirement.
I don’t blame Sirianni for trying something. When you’re 2-6 and the season’s real goals are already in a drawer somewhere, you might as well find out what you’ve got. That’s the one honest use of a lost year — you turn over rocks. Is Milton anything? Nobody knows. That’s exactly why you play him. You don’t learn a thing watching him hold a clipboard.
But let’s not dress it up as a bold new direction, either. This is a team taking inventory in the wreckage, and Sunday is the inventory. The Giants come in riding the better side of a season that’s gone the opposite direction from Philadelphia’s. On paper, this is a bad spot for the Birds. A first-time starter, a line that can’t protect him, and a division rival that’s actually figured a few things out. The betting world has already made up its mind, and it isn’t betting green.
Why the Linc fills anyway
So why will the Linc be full on Sunday? Why will South Jersey pile onto the bridges and into the lots at 2-6, for a Joe Milton start, in a season that’s functionally over?
Because that’s the deal. That’s always been the deal. You don’t get to be the kind of fan base that storms Broad Street in February and then stays home in November. We signed up for all of it — the parades and the Joe Milton auditions, the MVP seasons and the years the whole thing comes apart by Halloween. The name on the back of the jersey changes. The commitment doesn’t.
The name on the back of the jersey changes. The commitment doesn’t.Samuel Banks
Milton gets his shot Sunday. Here’s hoping the kid can run, because Lord knows nobody’s going to block for him.
Based on reporting from NFL Network, FOX Sports, the Delaware News Journal, and ESPN.
More Eagles Coverage
Samuel Banks will be watching Milton’s first start Sunday.
Read More Local News →